Announcing a Bitcoin treasury is no longer news on its own. Many companies have done it and more will follow. What sets leaders apart is not the purchase but the way they communicate it. A well-planned approach can build credibility with investors, analysts, and the press. A poorly handled one can create confusion.

If your company is considering this move, here are five common pitfalls to be aware of.

Weak Narrative Framing

The biggest mistake is leaving the “why” unclear. A short filing that says the company purchased Bitcoin does little to explain intent. Stakeholders want to know why this step makes sense for the business, how it supports long-term growth, and how leadership plans to manage it.

The narrative has to be consistent and straightforward. Tie the decision to an existing strategy, such as capital allocation discipline or commitment to digital innovation. Then use that framing and larger message everywhere, press releases, earnings scripts, investor decks, and interviews. If the reasoning changes depending on the audience, the company looks uncertain.

Forgetting the Audience

Too often, companies assume one message fits all. In practice, every audience looks at a Bitcoin treasury through a different lens. Investors want to know how it creates long-term value. Analysts care about risk management. The media want to place it in a broader industry context. Customers and partners care about continuity and trust.

That doesn’t mean writing a different story for each group, but it does mean tailoring emphasis based on which group you are talking to. For example, a press release should convey a broad and strategic message, while an investor presentation can go deeper. The goal is for every group to see the decision explained in terms that matter to them.

Hiding Leadership

People want to hear directly from leadership, especially the CEO and CFO. If the only voice is a press release, the story looks mechanical.

Firm communications plans put leadership front and center. That may involve an op-ed in a business outlet or a series of one-on-one interviews with top financial journalists. Other C-suite executives or other company directors can reinforce the message in investor forums or industry conferences. At the same time, comms leaders extend it through owned company channels like blogs, LinkedIn, or company newsletters. Each channel carries weight, but only if the voices and message are visible and coordinated.

Inconsistent Messaging Across Channels

One of the fastest ways to lose credibility is inconsistency. For example, if the press release emphasizes “long-term discipline” but the social posts sound promotional, or if analyst briefings focus on one goal while ignoring the other goals discussed in the press release, that’s where the audience can become confused.

Cross-channel consistency is critical. Earned media should reflect the same framing as owned content on the corporate site. Investor relations decks and quarterly reports should use the same language as leadership interviews; even if the wording isn’t identical, the overall key message needs to be the same. When all channels reinforce each other, the story feels intentional and credible.

Stopping at the Announcement

A Bitcoin treasury is not a one-day story. Markets move, and every swing brings questions back to the surface. If a company goes silent after the first announcement, coverage quickly shifts.

The solution is ongoing communication. This can include quarterly reporting that places Bitcoin within broader capital allocation, as well as periodic commentary from leadership on the continuing impact the treasury is having on the business. Proactive messaging also matters when volatility spikes. Having prepared talking points that reinforce the long-term strategy can help prevent reactive comments.

Beyond updates, the strongest companies take it a step further and position themselves as thought leaders. Publishing perspectives, engaging in roundtables, or offering commentary on digital asset policy helps companies move the narrative and have more influence within their industry. This begins to shift the perspective from a company defending a bitcoin treasury decision to shaping the broader conversation around it.

The Takeaway

Communicating a Bitcoin treasury strategy is not about convincing the world to buy into digital assets. It is about demonstrating that your company has a straightforward and disciplined approach, and can articulate it consistently. Avoid weak framing, think carefully about your audience, put leadership forward, keep every channel aligned, and plan for the long game.

Handled this way, communications becomes the differentiator. The numbers may appear similar across balance sheets, but the way a company explains its decisions determines whether it builds trust and maintains its momentum within the broader marketplace.

If you’re interested in learning more about the investor side of things when it comes to a digital asset strategy plan, read our Executive Playbook here.

You can also contact us to learn more about how Gateway supports companies with public relations and capital markets positioning in the digital asset space.

‍